The early 21st century has been characterized by governments which despise the people in whose name they hold power. While this has always been true of military dictators and socialist/communist governments, it has become the norm of both European and North American "liberal democracies" who hold their citizens in contempt while advancing their preferred elites.
This same sentiment, which has been a virulent undercurrent in the Vatican hierarchy in the last 50 years (I was born in the reign of Pius XII and remember the deaths of John XXIII & Paul VI clearly), has come to the surface in all its arrogance during the papacies of Francis I & now Leo XIV, who pursues Francis's policies, although he is better dressed.
In a sense, the "revolt" of the SSPX is (oddly) another facet of the Populism which has risen in Western societies as a response to the govening "elites", a call to return "ad fontes". Is it grief-making? Assuredly, but it may also come to be recognized as what Pope John Paul II said of the Protestant Reformation: "that tragic necessity".
An outstanding analysis. Thank you. I find myself very much on the side of SSPX, emotionally. Even as I acknowledge the logical inconsistencies which you point out.
I find the SSPX position perplexing… the Pope is infallible and when the Pope tells me not to consecrate bishops I do it anyway - how does this make sense? They seem like smart guys so I'm sure they've thought about this, perhaps the inevitable logic of their position has not yet reached them and they are holding out hope their side will win still and be vindicated I guess?
VATICAN v SSPX DRAMA IS JUST A JOKE & ITS ON YOU ALL…!! THEY, THE “ORTHODOX” & OVERWELMINGLY MOST SO CALLED “CHRISTAINS” ALL EQUALLY HERETICAL IN THE MOST DAMNDABLE WAYS POSSIBLE …… CURRENT EVENTS ARE AN INTENTIONALY SET “SELF DESTRUCT” ….. FYI
#1 "IRONICALLY", Trinitarians on one side & (JW & Islam-Muslims) on the other, are two opposite extrems of the SAME EXACT HERESY that makes Jesus a different person.
[FOLLOW THE PRONOUNS: the ONE SENDING is THE ONE SENT!! (same person sending & anouncing he is going to send his servant & he himself is the servant that he is sending)]
Isaiah 43:10 Ye are my witnesses, saith the LORD, and 👉MY SERVANT👈 whom 👉I👈 have chosen: that ye may KNOW and BELIEVE 👉me👈, and UNDERSTAND that
👉✝️I AM HE✝️👈...........11 I, even I, am the LORD; and 💢👉BESIDE ME👈 THERE IS NO SAVIOR💢. 43:13 Yea, BEFORE THE DAY was✝️I AM HE✝️;
John 8:24....IF YE BELIEVE NOT that ✝️I AM HE✝️, ye shall DIE IN YOUR SINS…. 28. ... LIFTED UP the Son of man, THEN shall ye KNOW that ✝️I AM HE✝️ .....58 Jesus said.....BEFORE Abraham was, ✝️I AM ✝️. 59 Then took they up stones to cast at him:...) 👈SPECIFIC TIME JESUS SPECIFICALY CLAIMS TO BE GOD & THEY UNDERSTOOD HIM PERFECTLY!!
“WHO” it was (what person) that came “IN THE FLESH”, IS THE DETERMINING FACTOR IN WHAT IT MEANS TO BE “ANT-CHRIST”! Even Islam claims Jesus was the Jewish messiah/Christ who was to come in the flesh) they all deny “WHO” it was (what person) that came (to be the Christ) in the flesh!?!…….
1Jn 2:22...Who is a liar but he who denies that Jesus is the Christ? He is antichrist who denies the Father and the Son. Whoever denies the Son does not have the Father either; he who acknowledges the Son has the Father also.”....You cant claim to believe that "I am HE" if you believe Jesus is a different person then God Father because to you Jesus is not HE but "some other different person sent by Him"!?!
To deny the father is to deny the son because they are one and the same person that came in the flesh!
👉TRINITARIANS CONFESS THEY ARE NOT POLYTHEIST BUT MONOTHEIST LIKE A LIAR & THIEF WHO “CONFESS” THEY DO NOT LIE OR STEAL👈
Satan in The garden…God said you will die…Satan comes along and states no you will be more WISE……today .God said He is one; but Satan’s children come along and say no three is more WISE and humble in the face of God’s grandeur only “a mystery” that can be understood incomprenesible faith. ….. Trinitarian heretics say to the effect: “NO, that is just a figure of speech, or that is not what God really means. What God is really saying is that God is three different persons”.
SO HOW CAN ONE PERSON BE IN MULTIPLE DIFFERENT PLACES SPEAKING AT ONCE?
REF: DIAGRAM:
Scripture points out that "in him we live move & have our being."
Imagine the white potion of this diagram extending in all directions infinitely.(2D or 3D) All time, past present & future, all space and all energy of heaven & earth exist within limits & bounds set & defined within this infinity. All creatures are finite with finite time, knowledge power et al. Time itself is a defined limitation. Even which way “cause & effect” & or “the arrow of time flows is a finite defined set within this infinity.]
#2 JESUS ISNT COMMING BACK …& THE OFFICE OF POPE IS PURE FRAUD TO BEGIN WITH……… SO CONFIDENT & “AUTHORITSTIVE”….. THIS ENDS POORLY …. “I NEVER KNEW YOU”
👉 2 Tim 4: 4... shall turn away their ears from the truth, and shall be TURNED UNTO FABLES.... 8 , shall give me AT THAT DAY: and not to me only, but UNTO ALL THEM also that 👉LOVE HIS APPEARING👈💣IMPOSSIBLE to love an appearing U deny!?! (context= AD70 2nd comming of "that day")
The early 21st century has been characterized by governments which despise the people in whose name they hold power. While this has always been true of military dictators and socialist/communist governments, it has become the norm of both European and North American "liberal democracies" who hold their citizens in contempt while advancing their preferred elites.
This same sentiment, which has been a virulent undercurrent in the Vatican hierarchy in the last 50 years (I was born in the reign of Pius XII and remember the deaths of John XXIII & Paul VI clearly), has come to the surface in all its arrogance during the papacies of Francis I & now Leo XIV, who pursues Francis's policies, although he is better dressed.
In a sense, the "revolt" of the SSPX is (oddly) another facet of the Populism which has risen in Western societies as a response to the govening "elites", a call to return "ad fontes". Is it grief-making? Assuredly, but it may also come to be recognized as what Pope John Paul II said of the Protestant Reformation: "that tragic necessity".
Well said, Father.
An outstanding analysis. Thank you. I find myself very much on the side of SSPX, emotionally. Even as I acknowledge the logical inconsistencies which you point out.
Thank you for this. I've had similar thoughts and also felt deeply grieved.
Well said, thank you.
I find the SSPX position perplexing… the Pope is infallible and when the Pope tells me not to consecrate bishops I do it anyway - how does this make sense? They seem like smart guys so I'm sure they've thought about this, perhaps the inevitable logic of their position has not yet reached them and they are holding out hope their side will win still and be vindicated I guess?
Nevertheless I am rooting for them.
VATICAN v SSPX DRAMA IS JUST A JOKE & ITS ON YOU ALL…!! THEY, THE “ORTHODOX” & OVERWELMINGLY MOST SO CALLED “CHRISTAINS” ALL EQUALLY HERETICAL IN THE MOST DAMNDABLE WAYS POSSIBLE …… CURRENT EVENTS ARE AN INTENTIONALY SET “SELF DESTRUCT” ….. FYI
#1 "IRONICALLY", Trinitarians on one side & (JW & Islam-Muslims) on the other, are two opposite extrems of the SAME EXACT HERESY that makes Jesus a different person.
[FOLLOW THE PRONOUNS: the ONE SENDING is THE ONE SENT!! (same person sending & anouncing he is going to send his servant & he himself is the servant that he is sending)]
Isaiah 43:10 Ye are my witnesses, saith the LORD, and 👉MY SERVANT👈 whom 👉I👈 have chosen: that ye may KNOW and BELIEVE 👉me👈, and UNDERSTAND that
👉✝️I AM HE✝️👈...........11 I, even I, am the LORD; and 💢👉BESIDE ME👈 THERE IS NO SAVIOR💢. 43:13 Yea, BEFORE THE DAY was✝️I AM HE✝️;
John 8:24....IF YE BELIEVE NOT that ✝️I AM HE✝️, ye shall DIE IN YOUR SINS…. 28. ... LIFTED UP the Son of man, THEN shall ye KNOW that ✝️I AM HE✝️ .....58 Jesus said.....BEFORE Abraham was, ✝️I AM ✝️. 59 Then took they up stones to cast at him:...) 👈SPECIFIC TIME JESUS SPECIFICALY CLAIMS TO BE GOD & THEY UNDERSTOOD HIM PERFECTLY!!
“WHO” it was (what person) that came “IN THE FLESH”, IS THE DETERMINING FACTOR IN WHAT IT MEANS TO BE “ANT-CHRIST”! Even Islam claims Jesus was the Jewish messiah/Christ who was to come in the flesh) they all deny “WHO” it was (what person) that came (to be the Christ) in the flesh!?!…….
1Jn 2:22...Who is a liar but he who denies that Jesus is the Christ? He is antichrist who denies the Father and the Son. Whoever denies the Son does not have the Father either; he who acknowledges the Son has the Father also.”....You cant claim to believe that "I am HE" if you believe Jesus is a different person then God Father because to you Jesus is not HE but "some other different person sent by Him"!?!
To deny the father is to deny the son because they are one and the same person that came in the flesh!
👉TRINITARIANS CONFESS THEY ARE NOT POLYTHEIST BUT MONOTHEIST LIKE A LIAR & THIEF WHO “CONFESS” THEY DO NOT LIE OR STEAL👈
Satan in The garden…God said you will die…Satan comes along and states no you will be more WISE……today .God said He is one; but Satan’s children come along and say no three is more WISE and humble in the face of God’s grandeur only “a mystery” that can be understood incomprenesible faith. ….. Trinitarian heretics say to the effect: “NO, that is just a figure of speech, or that is not what God really means. What God is really saying is that God is three different persons”.
SO HOW CAN ONE PERSON BE IN MULTIPLE DIFFERENT PLACES SPEAKING AT ONCE?
REF: DIAGRAM:
Scripture points out that "in him we live move & have our being."
Imagine the white potion of this diagram extending in all directions infinitely.(2D or 3D) All time, past present & future, all space and all energy of heaven & earth exist within limits & bounds set & defined within this infinity. All creatures are finite with finite time, knowledge power et al. Time itself is a defined limitation. Even which way “cause & effect” & or “the arrow of time flows is a finite defined set within this infinity.]
20pg CLIFTS NOTES VERSION
https://www.scribd.com/document/844419833/20-Page-Summary-PDF-1
Full book
https://www.scribd.com/doc/305367608/The-Trinity-Heresy
https://www.academia.edu/23463667/THE_TRINITY_HERESY
"Childeren of a lesser God"
https://allendaves.substack.com/p/children-of-a-lesser-god?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=1xhldx
#2 JESUS ISNT COMMING BACK …& THE OFFICE OF POPE IS PURE FRAUD TO BEGIN WITH……… SO CONFIDENT & “AUTHORITSTIVE”….. THIS ENDS POORLY …. “I NEVER KNEW YOU”
👉 2 Tim 4: 4... shall turn away their ears from the truth, and shall be TURNED UNTO FABLES.... 8 , shall give me AT THAT DAY: and not to me only, but UNTO ALL THEM also that 👉LOVE HIS APPEARING👈💣IMPOSSIBLE to love an appearing U deny!?! (context= AD70 2nd comming of "that day")
https://allendaves.substack.com/p/the-gospel-simultaneous-doom-and?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=1xhldx
https://allendaves.substack.com/p/the-man-of-sin-a-falling-away666the?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=1xhldx